I have always wanted to visit Sicily, and everyone I know who traveled there said wonderful things, so I had high expectations for my recent trip. Those expectations were far exceeded as I fell in love with Sicily – the people, the food, the scenery. There were beautiful baroque towns, sandy beaches with crystal clear water, green mountains, flower-filled valleys, smoking volcanoes and quaint off-shore islands. We walked through pristine vineyards, fragrant orange, pistachio, almond and olive groves, Greek temples, Roman amphitheaters and colorful local markets. Local produce, meats, fish and cheese were at the center of every meal, and the Sicilian staple of fresh ricotta and honey was a true revelation. From the hotel staff, to the workers picking oranges who insisted we stop for a sample and the shopkeepers who always proudly offered us a taste of their wares, the people of Sicily were warm and welcoming. It was impossible not to be charmed.
More ‘Big Apple Bites’, here: https://theconnectionsnj.com/category/big-apple-bites/
Sicily is the largest island in the Mediterranean and an intriguing crossroads of cultures and civilizations. Over the centuries, it has been part of Greater Greece, a Roman province, a Byzantine stronghold, an Arab Caliphate, a Norman kingdom, a pawn for Spain and the Bourbons, and finally part of a unified Italy. This dramatic cross-cultural mix is reflected in the island’s architecture, agriculture, cooking, language and social mores. It is what makes the culture distinctly Sicilian and very different from that of the Italian mainland.
The bounty of Sicily’s food and agriculture as well as the high degree of excellence of cooking at all levels was impressive. I went with a list of Sicilian specialties I wanted to sample, and I checked off every one. We enjoyed delicious focaccia at a local grocery, amazing sandwiches at a deli in the Ortigia market and the best swordfish in a small port town. We had freshly picked wild fennel and orange salads, amazing pasta with sardines, terrific caponata, and of course quite a bit of two of Sicily’s most famous treats, cannoli and gelato. There are many wonderful places to eat, but a few of our favorites are listed below. If you are considering a visit to Sicily, I highly recommend it.
SOME FAVORITE SPOTS
Antica Dolceria Benajuto, 159 Corso Umberto 1, Modica – a small elegant sweetshop with high quality cocoa-based chocolates, nougat torrone, and specialty cookies like the fig-filled nucatoli and the ‘mpantigghi – pastries filled with chocolate, spices and ground beef (very delicious)
Caffe Sicilia, 125 Corso Vittorio Emanuele, Noto – possibly the best gelateria in Sicily – some say the world – and they’ve been making top-rated pastries for over 100 years as well, the Montezuma gelato (chocolate, cinnamon, orange- and lemon-peel) was outstanding, but it is all great
Da Salvatore, Piazza San Michele, Petralia Soprana – Salvatore is the owner and host of this trattoria and pizzeria located in a beautiful little hill town in north central Sicily, delicious home cooking with daily specials, a sautéed mushroom dish and ricotta frittata were highlights
La Salumeria dei Fratelli Burgio, in the market in Ortigia, Siracusa – an Italian deli, cheese shop, gourmet food emporium, everything is homemade, the sandwiches are works of art, the bread amazing, caponata and salads are delicious, grab a table out front or get something to go, lots of great foodstuffs to bring back to the States
Osteria Nero D’Avalo, 2b Piazza San Domenico, Taormina – lovely restaurant in a quiet setting, veranda seating, sophisticated take on local specialties like fennel, eggplant, sword fish and seasonal game, a top choice in Taormina
Pasticceria Artigianale Grammatico Maria, 14 via Vittorio Emanuele, Erice – the recipes for the pastries are centuries old and come from the sisters of the San Carlo Monastery in Erice, the cannoli, fig and almond cookies and sesame seed biscuits are top notch, there is a coffee bar in the back of the bakery where you can enjoy your tray of pastries with a cappuccino, espresso or a cup of tea
Porto San Paolo, 1 Largo San Paolo, Sciacca – lovely casual restaurant on the top floor of a building nestled on the edge of the port, beautiful water views and food to match, excellent caponata, fennel salad, and the best swordfish of the trip – on a island where swordfish is the daily catch on every menu
Pura Follia, 92 via Nazionale, Scicli – incredible pizzas cooked in a wood burning oven with local seasonal ingredients and a choice of crusts from traditional to chia, flaxseed or quinoa flour, a broad range of artisanal beers too, the “Profuma di Sicilia” with mozzarella cheese, wild fennel sauce, tomatoes, basil, anchovies and toasted breadcrumbs (used in place of parmesan cheese throughout Sicily) and a crust made of antique grains was pizza heaven
Ristorante Crocifisso, 48 via Principe Umberto, Noto – a small, beautifully-designed restaurant with outstanding food and service, the meal was impeccable from start to finish, the caccio et pepe mussels and the pasta with sardines, pine nuts, raisins and fennel were incredible, terrific wine list too, a regional standout and a top 10 in Sicily
Tischi Toschi, 3 Vico Francesco Paladini, Taormina – a lively and fun spot to try the specialties of the house family-style, leave the ordering to the waiter and enjoy fennel and orange salad, caponata, grilled sardines, baked cheese, pasta with the fish of the day, and of course cannoli for dessert